I was almost trembling as I made my way upstairs and into the shower. I shaved my whiskers and lathered up anywhere and everywhere, my mind spinning. Wow! Me and Cindy! Of course it was just a hand job but, instead of my wife stroking ma and describing her little sister, it would be me and Cindy! I toweled off and put on my robe before exiting the bathroom, not sure what to expect in the adjacent bedroom.
The lights were dim but, when my eyes adjusted, I saw Cindy there under the covers. Waiting for me. I made a quick stop at the CD player and put on Mile's Kind of Blue album for a little mood music, then I glanced again at Cindy in my bed.
And, believe it or not, I started to get cold feet! Gee, was this something I really wanted to do? I truly did love Melissa and always appreciated how sexually adventurous she was. Was this something we would both regret? I mean, we couldn't take a sexual encounter...even a hand job, we couldn't take that back, you know?
So, it was with a bit of hesitation that I sat down on the bed and looked down at my little sister in law. As usual, she wore that half smile and her beautiful hazel eyes were shining up to me. It was almost like she had somehow already managed to get past the trepidation that I was experiencing. She seemed to recognize that unsure look on my face.
"Sam, if you want, you can just tell me about how you and Melissa do it. I don't want to, you know, get you into any kind of, you know, make any trouble between you and my sister." She said softly.
Remember that old song that Lucy and Ricky sang on the "I love Lucy show?" "Man Smart, Woman Smarter?" Here was my little virgin sister in law trying to make it easy on me. Right about then, I realized I had nothing to fear from this encounter.
"I'll tell you what," I began, "If either of us thinks we're heading for trouble, we can call it off...but I don't think that'll happen!" I said smiling down at her. Cindy looked so beautiful lying there under the covers. I dropped my robe and climbed under the covers naked and reached for her.
"Well, Cind we usually start with a kiss!" I nodded my head at her and she closed her eyes and pursed her lips up at me. I wondered if she would just play it for laughs. It started out small...just a little smooching and nibbling but then it progressed until we were ferociously going at it. It was like all of the pent up desire I had for this gorgeous young creature came to the surface. She sucked softly on my tongue as I pressed her to me, feeling her tight little tits poking me in the chest. I reached down and was thrilled to feel that she hadn't shed her panties!
"Mmmmmm!" I moaned. "What color are your panties Cindy?"
"They're white Sam. Your favorite." She looked directly into my eyes and then said "I'm wearing white panties for you!" I gave an involuntary grunt and quickly reached for her skimpy underpants. Oh, they were soft and smooth and, just beneath, her virgin pussy awaited me!
More kissing ensued and then I felt it was time for Cindy to lube me up. I grabbed the Astroglide from the nightstand and told Cindy to get me all slippery and to use both hands.
She was a quick learner and easily had me hardening in her soft, well lubricated hands.
"Use both hands honey, and not too hard at first." I advised. "Now, usually, Melissa will come up with some kind of fantasy story about an old boyfriend or her first time doing anal or..."
"Or her little sister?" Cindy interrupted. "Her little sister's experiments with shaving. Shaving her...pussy?"
It was almost like Cindy had a hard time saying that last word but she got it out and my cock jerked when I heard it.
I also realized maybe the sisters had shared more information than I thought. I was at a loss for words. I knew then that Cindy understood my sexual fascination for her. I was quiet for a few moments. Then, as if she understood what I was feeling, Cindy spoke.
"What about you Sam?" She began. Maybe you could describe your first time to me and, you know, get me excited too!"
I wasn't prepared for that but Cindy just kissed me again and then snuggled up against me. She continued stroking my now rock hard cock until I collected my thoughts. I hadn't had a lot of sexual experience as a lad but there was this one girl I met when we were just 18 year old seniors. And so, I began...
"I had girlfriends in high school but I always seemed to date 'Nice Girls' who would never consider going all the way. This led to a lot of sexual frustration. Then, I met Darlene. We were in photography class together and the next thing I knew I'd asked her out to our school football game the upcoming Friday night. Well, we had fun cheering our team on and later we stopped at A&W for burgers and root beer. Darlene had moved over right next to me on the bench seat of my Dad's Impala and her body felt nice and warm there touching me."
Cindy moved even closer when she heard my narrative and continued to fondle my balls with one hand while slowly stroking me with the other. "Did you kiss her Sam?" She wondered.
"I did steal a kiss while we were waiting for our food and Darlene really seemed to like that! Well, afterwards I was driving her home assuming our evening was over. When we got to her street I went to make a right but Darlene grabbed the wheel and, smiling all the while, sent me a message: 'I don't want to go home just yet.' Knucklehead that I am, it took me a few moments to figure out what Darlene wanted to do instead of ending our date. Finally, I slowly drove up Zelzah to the hills overlooking the Valley. We were going to park! Darlene was hanging on my neck now as I found a scenic spot and parked the Chevy. And then, then we went at it! Loads of kisses and then, for my first time, French kisses! Darlene gave up waiting for Mr. Naive and just stuck her tongue into my mouth and wagged it all around which delighted me. Right about then, I began to steal my hand down to Darlene's knee and, encountering no resistance, I began to slide it up her leg, kissing her all the while as if to distract her. But Darlene didn't really need much in the way of distraction! No, she kept kissing and frenching me until, at last, I was touching her panties!"